What makes a crossover bad?
In the world of MSTings, it
has been proven time and time again that crossovers are almost invariably
bad or deficient in some way. There are countless crossover fics out there,
which include those that crossover Star Trek and Sailor Moon, Project A-ko
and Batman, and even Final Fantasy 7 and Ranma½. Here, we go in depth
to examine what exactly makes a crossover bad.
- Lack of ingenuity of
some crossovers. Shows that really don't mix require a lot of ingenuity
to make them work. It can be done, but it's not easy. (Unless you are writing
a spoof or parody, then it is a bit easier) Like if you wanted to cross
Thundercats with a soap opera (using examples of two shows I watch but
would never write a crossover for) (Butler)
- Personality or body
switching... having person from universe A end up in the body of someone
from universe B and having them be all confused about the show they have
been newly deposited on (Butler)
- The plot devices neccessary
to cross over shows. That wouldn't be so much of a complaint except that
it's plot devices even people with good stories tend to overuse, making it
all the worse if the story itself is bad. For example, the common amnesia
plotline. (Butler)
- Gonterman Effect.
The Gonterman Effect occurs any time when the author decides to throw
in an extra-crossover character in because he/she is too lazy to create a
new one. Ex.: David Gonterman decides that Gadget needs a girl
friend to talk to in his Sailor Moon USA comic. The problem is that
on the CDRR show never really had a re-acurring female character who was
Gadget's age, so rather than come up with a new character, David decides
to throw in Princess Sally from the Sonic the Hedgehog Comic to be
Gadget's new pal... (Karmacide)
Contributors: Tracy
Butler, Karmacide
Any more bad crossover qualities?
E-mail me
!
Back to MSTers Reference
Back to Lefty's MSTings
Back to Lefty's House O' MST